So In Love With Two by Mikaila

I'm actually not, but it's the same scenario. I don't kow what to do. Or maybe I do but I don't like the answer. In Mikaila's song I always say go with her Number Two and in this case my fist guy is my Number Two.

SO I'VE LIKED THIS GUY FOR A LONG TIME.
So we're talking on facebook(the root of all evil) and we decide the next time we see each other we'll go together. Then he's taking a while so my friend says forget about him and pushes me to go with this super nice and hot guy. We're together but I don't like him that much. Now the first guy is here again and he's asked me out.
     My friend however, and her sis, thinks I'm and idiot cause the guy I like isn't hot and appearantly just wants to get in my pants. I'm still a virgin. They of all people should know I wont give it up just like that. Anyways even if that's all he wants, I want to know. I'm a female and all females just want to know the truth, right?
     My other friend has told me to follow my heart and not let others influence my thinking. I think she's right..wait scratch that. I KNOW she's right. Now all that's left is the hard part.
IT'S A PART OF LIFE
I don't know how to break up with my super nice guy.  He's so sweet and he always textes me Good Morning in the morning. He's a really good kisser. He makes me laugh...sometimes.
ON THE OTHER HAND
Do you know we have nothing in common. Talking to him is horrible because I'm the worst conversationalist in the world. All our conversations consist of him talking and me laughing, sometimes fake. None of my jokes are funny to him but I think they're super hilarious so I want to laugh so loud but I can't.  
IT'S A VERY HARD PART OF LIFE
I still don't know how to do it but i have to, not because of some other guy but for me cause i don't like him.
SHE HATES ME NOW
Did I metion she'll never speak to me again and will start plotting my demise if she reads this post?
WHO SHOULD I PICK???
My Number One or My Number Two?